Neither one is the better company, and the usual tiebreaker does not help here, because both of them write indexed universal life and both reach you through a licensed agent rather than an online checkout. What separates them is what each company built around that policy: National Life Group organizes its story around living benefits, the idea that a qualifying illness can put money in your hands while you are still here, on a shelf that runs term, whole life and indexed universal life. Pacific Life is arranged around the longer plan, with term, a deep set of permanent designs, survivorship coverage that pays after the second of two people dies, and annuity, investment and workforce benefits businesses sitting beside the life company. If the worry that keeps you up is what happens to you during a long illness, one of those shapes speaks to it directly, and if the worry is what a plan leaves behind, the other one does.
At a glance
| National Life Group | Pacific Life | |
|---|---|---|
| In business since | 1848, when National Life Insurance Company was chartered in Vermont | 1868, one of the older life insurers still writing today |
| Company structure | A trade name over a family of financial services companies | A mutual holding company structure, Pacific Mutual Holding Company |
| Who issues the policy | National Life Insurance Company or Life Insurance Company of the Southwest | Pacific Life Insurance Company or Pacific Life and Annuity Company |
| Home offices | Montpelier, Vermont, with a second home office in Texas | Newport Beach, California, insurer home office in Omaha, Nebraska |
| Individual life shelf | Term, whole life and indexed universal life | Term, universal, indexed universal, variable universal and survivorship |
| Best known for | Indexed universal life and living benefits riders | A deep permanent line and survivorship coverage |
| How you buy it | Through a licensed agent, who walks the underwriting result back | Through a licensed financial professional, not an online checkout |
| Beyond individual life | Annuities, retirement plans, IRAs and mutual funds | Annuities, investment products and workforce benefits |
| Financial strength | Look the exact issuing company up at ambest.com | Look the exact issuing company up at ambest.com |
Living benefits out front, or survivorship and the longer plan
Product type is the tiebreaker people expect to use, and it settles nothing here, because indexed universal life sits near the center of both companies. The difference that moves the decision is what each one put next to it. National Life Group builds its consumer story around living benefits, and they are the headline rather than a footnote: coverage that can pay you during your lifetime when a qualifying event happens. Living Benefits has its own place in the menu on the company's site, beside life insurance and annuities rather than buried in a rider list. Pacific Life put the emphasis further out. Beside term and a deep permanent line, it writes survivorship coverage that pays after the second of two insured people dies, a planning instrument rather than an income replacement one, and the life company sits under a mutual holding company with annuity, investment and workforce benefits businesses around it. Neither arrangement is the better one. One shelf is arranged around what a policy can do for you while you are living. The other is arranged around what a plan does after you are not, and most households know which of those two worries is theirs.
Who each one actually suits
National Life Group
A Vermont rooted group known for indexed universal life with living benefits
- Living benefits are the reason you are shopping, and you want them discussed on the first visit rather than found in the rider list later, which is how National Life leads on its own site.
- You want indexed universal life from a company where that product is the center of the shelf rather than one option among many.
- You like the idea of a policy from a group whose oldest member was chartered in Vermont in 1848 and is still writing coverage under that name.
- You want one agent handling life insurance and the retirement side, since the group also offers annuities, retirement plans, IRAs and mutual funds.
- You want the rider list and its state specific terms explained plainly before you sign, since living benefit availability and wording vary from one state to the next.
Pacific Life
A large California insurer under a mutual holding company with a broad shelf
- Level term is the job for now, and you like that the same company keeps a deep permanent line you could look at later.
- You and a spouse are planning together and survivorship coverage is on the table, since Pacific Life writes second to die policies alongside its single life shelf.
- You want more than one permanent design set side by side, cash value credited from an interest rate, from an index, or from investment subaccounts you select.
- Scale matters to you, and a company in business since 1868 with annuity, investment and workforce benefits businesses around the life company reads as steady.
- You would rather have an independent agent price Pacific Life beside several other carriers, since its coverage is placed through licensed financial professionals rather than an online checkout.
If you already hold one of them
If either one is already in a drawer at your house, the first job is to read it, not to replace it. Ask the issuing company for an in force illustration, the document that shows whether an indexed universal life policy is funded the way it was originally designed, and read the guaranteed column next to the projected one. On a National Life policy, check the first page for which member company issued the contract and check which living benefit riders are attached, because that is the part people forget they own, and on a Pacific Life policy, check the first page for the same reason and ask, if what you hold is term, whether it is convertible and when that window closes. Plenty of these reviews end with keep what you have, and we will tell you so plainly when that is the answer.
Common questions
Do both of these companies sell indexed universal life?
Yes, and that is why they end up on the same shortlist. National Life Group lists indexed universal life among its individual products and is best known for it, and Pacific Life writes indexed universal life alongside universal life and variable universal life. In both cases the mechanics are the same in shape: the cash value is credited based on the movement of an index rather than being invested in the market directly, with a floor that limits what a down year can take and a cap or participation rate that limits what an up year can add. The differences that matter are in the specific contract, so the useful comparison is two illustrations for the same face amount and the same funding, not two brochures.
Which company is actually named on the policy?
A member company, at both of them, and it is worth checking rather than assuming. National Life Group describes itself as a trade name representing a family of financial services companies, and the insurers inside it include National Life Insurance Company, chartered in Vermont in 1848, and Life Insurance Company of the Southwest, a Texas company. Pacific Life works the same way on a smaller scale, with Pacific Life Insurance Company and Pacific Life and Annuity Company both appearing on contracts. At either one, which company issued yours depends on the product and the state, and the name is printed on the first page of the policy. Look up that exact name rather than the brand on the envelope, and you can check its current financial strength at ambest.com.
What are living benefits, and does Pacific Life offer anything similar?
Living benefits let you draw on part of the death benefit while you are alive if a qualifying event happens, such as a terminal, chronic or critical illness, under the terms the rider spells out. National Life Group leads with them on its own site, where Living Benefits sits in the menu beside life insurance and annuities. Accelerated benefit riders in some form are common across large carriers now, so the right question at Pacific Life is not whether the idea exists but which riders are available on the exact product you are being shown and in your state. Availability and wording vary by state at every carrier, and New York is often its own case. Ask for the rider list in writing on both. One more thing worth knowing: accelerating a benefit reduces what is left for your beneficiary later.
Can I buy from either one online?
Not in the way you can buy a phone plan. Pacific Life points consumers to a licensed financial professional, and its own material notes that anyone selling its life insurance has to be a properly licensed and appointed producer. National Life describes an application that runs through underwriting, with an agent contacting you to go over the result and the details of the policy. That is normal for permanent coverage and it is not a drawback. Indexed universal life is designed rather than picked off a shelf, and the funding level chosen at the start changes how the policy behaves for decades, which is a conversation rather than a checkout.
My illustration shows a large number decades out. Should I count on it?
Read the guaranteed column, then read the projected column, then treat the space between them as the range of outcomes rather than a promise. An indexed universal life illustration projects forward using an assumed crediting rate, and caps, participation rates and the cost of insurance all move over the life of a policy. That is true at both of these companies and at every other carrier writing this product. The honest way to compare two illustrations is to ask for them at the same assumed rate, the same face amount and the same premium, and to look at what happens if you fund at the minimum instead of the level shown. If the numbers only work at the top of the page, that is worth knowing before you sign.
Will I need a medical exam at either one?
It depends on the product, the amount, your age, your health answers and your state, at both companies, and neither one runs on a single rule. Larger permanent policies more often call for an exam at any carrier, simply because the company is being asked to take on more, while smaller amounts on healthy applicants can sometimes clear on health questions and database checks. National Life runs applications through underwriting and has an agent walk the result back to you, and Pacific Life places coverage through a licensed professional the same way. So the practical move is to ask early what your own case is likely to require rather than guessing from a website.
Which one is cheaper?
There is no honest answer before your details are known, and any figure quoted in the abstract is an average rather than your price. What you pay turns on your age, your health, tobacco use, the face amount, your state and above all which product is being priced. A term quote and an indexed universal life illustration are not the same purchase, so setting one premium beside the other tells you almost nothing. Decide the job first, whether that is twenty years of income protection or permanent coverage with cash value, then have that same job priced at both companies and at two or three others, and the comparison becomes readable.
Free · No obligation
The right answer depends on you, not on the brochure.
Rates for National Life Group and Pacific Life both depend on your age and health, which means the better buy for your neighbour may be the worse buy for you. A licensed professional will price both against what you already have and tell you which is genuinely better, including when the honest answer is to keep what you have.
Mon-Sat · 10am-9pm
This comparison is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Product availability, pricing and underwriting differ by state, age and health, and change over time. Policy Review Center is a free comparison and referral service, not an insurance agency, insurer, or producer, and it connects you with independent licensed agents. Carrier names are used for reference only and do not imply any endorsement or affiliation.