Neither one is the better company, and the two are more alike than most people expect. Both sell life insurance with no medical exam, and both can be bought without an agent ever sitting at your table. What differs is the door you walk through. TruStage reaches most people through a credit union they already belong to, and its shelf includes a guaranteed acceptance whole life plan that asks no health questions, with a two year limit on natural causes written into that plan. Globe Life reaches households directly, and its direct life pages advertise a simple yes or no application, no waiting period and full coverage the first day. Your health answers, and which plan they point to, decide it.
At a glance
| TruStage | Globe Life | |
|---|---|---|
| Who issues the policy | CMFG Life Insurance Company, with affiliated insurers on some plans | Globe Life And Accident (Globe Life of New York in NY) |
| Company structure | Mutual holding company structure, based in Madison, Wisconsin | Part of Globe Life Inc., a publicly traded holding company in McKinney, Texas |
| Where the offer usually comes from | Your credit union, which is why the name already feels familiar | A mailer, a television spot or a web search, sent straight to you |
| How you apply | Online or by phone in minutes, no agent visit | Online, by mailed information packet, by phone, or with an agent |
| Life plans offered | Term to age 80, whole life, guaranteed acceptance whole life | Term, whole life, final expense, children's life, accidental death |
| Underwriting | No medical exam. A few questions on term and whole life, none on guaranteed acceptance | No medical exam. A simple yes or no application on the direct plans |
| The first two years | Guaranteed acceptance: premiums paid plus 10 percent, accidents in full | Direct pages state no waiting period, full coverage the first day |
| Coverage amounts shown online | Not published. Quoted by plan, age and state | Adult plans advertised at $100,000, children's life to $30,000 |
| Rest of the shelf | Auto, home, renters, accidental death and funeral plans | Mortgage protection plus cancer, hospital, critical illness and accident plans |
A plan that asks no health questions, or questions that buy first day coverage
Both companies skip the agent appointment, so the shopping feels similar until you read what the short application buys. TruStage is the brand for TruStage Financial Group, the Madison, Wisconsin company formerly known as CUNA Mutual Group, and its life policies are issued by CMFG Life Insurance Company. TruStage states a close relationship with more than 3,200 credit unions, which is how most people first see the offer, and its shelf carries three life plans, one of which asks no health questions at all. The trade for that plan is printed in the contract: a death from natural causes in the first two years returns 100 percent of the premiums paid plus 10 percent, and accidental death is paid in full. Globe Life sits inside Globe Life Inc., a publicly traded holding company in McKinney, Texas, and reaches households through the mail, television and its own site. Its direct life pages advertise no medical exam, a simple yes or no application, no waiting period and full coverage the first day. Those questions are what buys the first day benefit. Both doors are real. Which one fits depends on how your health answers read.
Who each one actually suits
TruStage
Credit union brand whose life policies are issued by CMFG Life
- You belong to a credit union that offers it, and you would rather buy coverage from a place you already do business with.
- Health questions are the part you dread, and the guaranteed acceptance whole life plan asks none of them.
- You want to finish the application yourself, online or by phone, in a single sitting.
- You want term coverage that can run to age 80, and you are comfortable with the rate stepping up every five years at a new age band.
- You like that one brand can also hold your auto, home and renters coverage, so the paperwork lives in one place.
Globe Life
Direct response insurer that reaches households by mail and television
- You can answer a short yes or no health application, and you want the full benefit payable from the first day.
- You would rather read the rates on paper at your own pace, so a mailed information packet suits how you decide.
- You want a familiar national name and an application you can finish without an appointment.
- You are covering a child or grandchild, since children's life insurance is advertised up to $30,000.
- You may want supplemental health or accident coverage alongside the life policy, from the same company.
If you already hold one of them
If you hold the TruStage policy, start by finding the insurer named on the contract, because plenty of people believe the credit union carries the coverage, and it does not. CMFG Life Insurance Company issues most of these policies, the contract stands on its own, and closing the credit union account does not cancel it, though it can break the draft the premium comes out of. If you hold the Globe Life policy, check the beneficiary and the face amount against what your household would actually need today. In both cases the coverage was priced on the health you had the day it was issued, and that is usually worth more than a fresh quote, so keeping what you have is a perfectly good answer.
Common questions
Which is better, TruStage or Globe Life?
Neither, in the abstract. They sell to the same kind of buyer through two different front doors. TruStage reaches most people through a credit union, and its shelf includes a guaranteed acceptance whole life plan that asks no health questions, which suits someone whose health history has made shopping awkward. Globe Life reaches people directly and its direct pages state no waiting period and full coverage from the first day, which suits someone who can answer a short yes or no application and wants the benefit payable right away. What either costs depends on your age, your health and your state, so the honest answer only comes from quoting both.
Do I have to belong to a credit union to buy TruStage life insurance?
TruStage is built around credit unions and states a close relationship with more than 3,200 of them, which is how most people first see the offer. It also quotes and takes applications on its own site and by phone. Eligibility rules can vary by plan and by state, so the quickest way to settle it is to ask TruStage directly or have a licensed professional check for you before you fill anything out. Globe Life has no membership requirement of any kind.
Why does the company name on the policy differ from the name on the ad?
Because in both cases the brand and the issuing insurer are different names, which is normal and not a red flag. TruStage is the brand for TruStage Financial Group, the company formerly known as CUNA Mutual Group, and its insurance products are issued by CMFG Life Insurance Company and affiliated insurers. Globe Life policies are issued by Globe Life And Accident Insurance Company, with Globe Life Insurance Company of New York issuing for New York residents. The insurer printed on your own contract is the one that governs, so read that page and keep it with your records.
Does either one require a medical exam?
No, and that is a big part of why people compare these two. TruStage states no medical exams or intrusive tests on its life plans, and its guaranteed acceptance whole life goes further with no health questions either. Globe Life advertises no medical exam and a simple application across its direct life plans. Hold on to the distinction between no exam and no questions, though, because it decides which plan you are offered and what the early years look like.
If I died in the first two years, would each one pay the full benefit?
That is the sharpest difference between them, and the detail people miss is that it is plan specific rather than company wide. TruStage guaranteed acceptance whole life is the plan carrying the limitation: a death from natural causes in the first two years returns 100 percent of the premiums paid plus 10 percent rather than the full amount, accidental death is covered in full, and coverage starts once the first payment clears. That limitation is the trade for asking no health questions at all. Globe Life states on its direct life pages that there is no waiting period and full coverage applies from the first day, and the yes or no health questions on the application are what buys that. Same trade, viewed from two ends, so read the plan you are actually offered rather than the company name.
What happens to my TruStage policy if I close my credit union account?
The policy does not end. Your contract is with the insurer, not with the credit union, so the coverage, the premium and the beneficiary all stay exactly as they were. The practical risk is billing. If the premium drafts from the account you are closing, give the insurer new payment details before the account goes away, then confirm the next payment actually posted. A missed draft on a small policy is one of the most common ways good coverage quietly lapses.
Which one costs less?
There is no fixed answer, and anyone who gives you one without your details is guessing. Life insurance pricing turns on your age, your health answers, the plan, the coverage amount and the state you live in, and both of these companies price the same person differently depending on which plan the answers point to. A guaranteed acceptance plan and a plan that asks health questions are not really the same product, so comparing their monthly figures alone can mislead you. Run both quotes on your real numbers, then compare what each one actually pays and when.
If I already have one of these, should I switch to the other?
Not automatically, and often not at all. Coverage you already own was priced on the health you had when it was issued, so if your health has changed since, replacing it can cost more or may not be available on the same terms. Any honest comparison starts by valuing what you already hold, and a review that ends in keep what you have is a perfectly good result.
Can I hold policies from both companies at once?
Yes. There is no rule against owning coverage from more than one insurer, and plenty of households do, often because policies were bought at different life stages for different reasons. What matters is that the total coverage matches what your family would actually need, and that you are not paying twice for the same job.
Free · No obligation
The right answer depends on you, not on the brochure.
Rates for TruStage and Globe Life both depend on your age and health, which means the better buy for your neighbour may be the worse buy for you. A licensed professional will price both against what you already have and tell you which is genuinely better, including when the honest answer is to keep what you have.
Mon-Sat · 10am-9pm
This comparison is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Product availability, pricing and underwriting differ by state, age and health, and change over time. Policy Review Center is a free comparison and referral service, not an insurance agency, insurer, or producer, and it connects you with independent licensed agents. Carrier names are used for reference only and do not imply any endorsement or affiliation.