The most common objection to term insurance is a fair one: if I outlive the policy, I get nothing back. Return of premium is the answer to that, and it has a price.
Return of premium (ROP) life insurance is a term policy that refunds the premiums you paid if you are still living when the term ends. The Insurance Information Institute says the premiums are often significantly higher than for plain term, and you generally must keep the policy in force to the end or forfeit the refund. Whether it is worth it comes down to the price multiple, which the math below shows you how to test.
Torn between plain term and return of premium? A free, no-pressure conversation with a licensed professional who will run your numbers both ways.
What return of premium life insurance is
In most kinds of insurance, if you do not file a claim you get no refund, because your premium bought protection you had but did not need. The Insurance Information Institute explains that some consumers were unhappy with that outcome on term life, so some insurers created term policies with a return-of-premium feature. You buy the same term life coverage, a death benefit that pays only if you die during the term, plus a promise to refund what you paid if you outlive it.
How the refund works
- The term. You pick a length, such as 20 years. The Institute notes that 20-year term is now the most popular type of term policy.
- The premium. It is level, and higher than plain term for the same amount.
- The refund. Some policies return the base premium but not the extra premium that pays for the refund feature, and others return both, according to the Institute. This detail changes the math, so ask.
- The condition. The Institute says these policies generally require that you keep the policy in force to its term or else you forfeit the return-of-premium benefit.
The real math: what the refund actually costs
The refund equals what you paid, so the cost of the feature is the use of the money for 20 years, not the premium itself. Here is the worked example. The numbers are round, chosen to teach the math. They are not a quote.
Worked example · round numbers, not a quote
Say plain 20-year term costs $100 a month. An ROP policy for the same coverage might cost two, three, or four times that. Ask any carrier for the real multiple. For each multiple, the question is: what return would the extra monthly money have to earn elsewhere to match the refund?
20-year term · plain term at $100 a month · hypothetical ROP multiples
| ROP price multiple | ROP monthly premium | Total paid over 20 years | Refund if you outlive the term | Annual return the extra premium must earn elsewhere to match |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 times | $200 | $48,000 | $48,000 | about 6.3% |
| 3 times | $300 | $72,000 | $72,000 | about 3.8% |
| 4 times | $400 | $96,000 | $96,000 | about 2.8% |
Hypothetical arithmetic. Break-even compares putting the extra monthly premium (the ROP price minus $100) into an account with monthly compounding for 240 months against the full ROP refund. Before taxes and fees. Ignores the case where you die in the term and the case where you lapse. Real multiples vary by age, health, term, and carrier.
Read the last column. At twice the price, the extra money has to earn about 6.3% a year elsewhere to beat the refund. At four times the price, about 2.8% is enough. A higher multiple makes plain term plus a separate savings plan easier to win with, and a lower multiple makes ROP more competitive. That is why two people can get opposite answers to the same question.
How likely you are to collect
The refund is likely to be paid if you keep the policy, and the usual risk is lapsing, not dying. The CDC’s 2022 life table shows about 90.5% of all 40-year-olds alive 20 years later, and about 81% of 50-year-olds alive after 20 years. Insured applicants do better than the general population, so these are conservative.
| Age at purchase | 20-year term ends at | Share of the population still alive |
|---|---|---|
| 30 | 50 | about 94.8% |
| 40 | 60 | about 90.5% |
| 50 | 70 | about 81.2% |
Source: CDC National Center for Health Statistics, United States Life Tables, 2022 (NVSR vol. 74, no. 2), total population. General population figures, not insured lives.
So the question for most buyers is not “will I live to collect?” It is “will I still be paying in year 20?” Life changes, and a policy that costs two to four times plain term is easier to drop in a tight year. If a lapse is a real possibility, the forfeited-refund rule matters a great deal.
Want the math on your own numbers? We will price plain term and return of premium side by side for your age and health. No obligation, your decision.
ROP vs. plain term
| Plain term | Return of premium term | |
|---|---|---|
| Death benefit during the term | Pays | Pays |
| Monthly premium | Lowest for the coverage | Often significantly higher (Insurance Information Institute) |
| If you outlive the term | No refund | Refund of premiums, base only or base plus extra depending on the policy |
| If you stop paying early | Coverage ends | Coverage ends and the refund is generally forfeited |
| Best for | Most protection for the least money | Buyers who value a refund and will hold the full term |
Educational comparison. Pricing and refund terms vary by carrier and state.
The death benefit is the same in both. The only thing ROP adds is the refund, and the only thing it takes is a higher premium and a commitment to the full term. If you are still working out how much protection you need, start with how much life insurance you need. Price depends on age as well, which our chart of life insurance rates by age shows.
Questions to ask before you buy
Get these answers in writing
- The plain term price and the ROP price for the same amount and length.
- Whether the refund returns the base premium only, or the base plus the extra premium.
- What happens to the refund if you lapse, cancel, or stop paying before the end.
- Whether the policy can be converted to permanent coverage, and until what age.
- Whether you could hold the premium for the full term in a tight year.
- How a refund of premiums is treated for tax. Ask a tax professional.
On the death benefit itself: under Internal Revenue Code section 101(a), amounts paid by reason of the insured’s death are generally excluded from gross income, the same as on any policy. Our page on permanent life insurance covers the option that never expires, if the idea of a refund is really a wish for a policy that lasts.
When to skip it, and when not to call us
If your goal is the most protection for the least money while your children are young, plain term is usually the better fit. A mortgage and a young family need as much death benefit as the budget allows, and a higher premium reduces the amount you can afford. Plain term also asks for no 20-year commitment to preserve a benefit. The refund is also not a reason to buy more insurance than you need.
If you like the discipline of a policy that gives you something back, and you are confident you can hold it for the full term, ROP is a fair choice, and a quote on both lets the numbers decide. If you already own an ROP policy, keeping it is usually right unless the premium has become hard to carry, because stopping early can forfeit the refund. We will tell you that on a free call. A free policy review will check the refund schedule and tell you plainly whether to keep it, adjust it, or look at options. If the answer is keep what you have, that is a successful review.
Free · No pressure
See plain term and return of premium, side by side.
A licensed professional will price both for your age and health and walk through the real tradeoff with you, calmly, with no pressure. If plain term is the better fit, you will hear exactly that.
- Plain answers about return of premium coverage
- Reading a policy you already own
- Beneficiary, billing and premium questions
- Comparing options if you want them
Helping families since 2000. Licensed in all 50 states.
Mon-Sat · 10am-9pm
Questions people ask about return of premium
01What is return of premium life insurance?
Return of premium (ROP) life insurance is a term policy that refunds premiums if you are still living when the term ends. The Insurance Information Institute notes the premiums are often significantly higher than for a plain term policy, and that you generally must keep the policy in force to the end of the term or forfeit the refund. Some policies return the base premium but not the extra premium for the refund feature, and others return both.
02Is return of premium term life insurance worth it?
It depends on the price multiple and on whether you will keep the policy to the end. The refund equals what you paid, so the question is what the extra monthly premium would have earned elsewhere. In the worked example above, an ROP policy at twice the plain term price is matched by about a 6.3% annual return on the difference, and one at four times the price by about 2.8%. Ask for both quotes and run the numbers with an agent.
03How much more does return of premium cost than regular term?
The Insurance Information Institute says the premiums are often significantly higher than for policies without the feature. The multiple varies by age, term length, and carrier, so ask for a plain term quote and an ROP quote for the same amount and length. The ratio between them is the figure that drives the worth-it math.
04What happens if I cancel a return of premium policy early?
The Insurance Information Institute says these policies generally require that you keep the policy in force to its term or else you forfeit the return-of-premium benefit. Because the details vary by contract, ask the carrier for the refund schedule in writing before you buy. If a lapse would be a real possibility for you, that is a reason to lean toward plain term.
05How likely am I to collect the refund?
Most people who stay with the policy will. Using the CDC 2022 life table, about 90.5% of all 40-year-olds are alive 20 years later, and insured applicants tend to do better than the general population. The risk to the refund is usually not death. It is lapsing the policy before the term ends.
06Is the death benefit still tax-free on a return of premium policy?
The death benefit works the same way as on any life insurance policy: under Internal Revenue Code section 101(a), amounts paid by reason of the insured’s death are generally excluded from gross income. How a refund of premiums is treated is a separate question, so ask a tax professional. This is educational, not tax advice.
07Can I get return of premium on a 20-year or 30-year term?
Availability depends on the carrier and the term length. The Insurance Information Institute notes that 20-year term is now the most popular type of term policy. Pick the term length first, based on how long your family needs the protection, and then ask whether an ROP version is offered.