Neither one is the better company, because they are two different ways of buying much the same kind of coverage. American Amicable does not sell to the public directly, so you reach it through a licensed agent who asks the health questions, completes the application with you, and can usually set another carrier or two beside it. Globe Life is built so you can handle it on your own: pull a quote online, ask for an information packet with rates by mail, or call, with a simple application and no medical exam on the direct products, and it will connect you with an agent if you would rather have one. If you want someone to read your health answers and shop them, the agent route fits, and if you would rather start it yourself tonight, that is precisely what Globe Life is built for.
At a glance
| American Amicable | Globe Life | |
|---|---|---|
| Home office | Waco, Texas | McKinney, Texas |
| Company structure | Five insurance companies in the American Amicable Group | Part of Globe Life Inc., a publicly traded holding company |
| Who issues the policy | One of the five, depending on the product and your state | Globe Life And Accident (Globe Life of New York in NY) |
| How you buy it | Through a licensed agent, not a web checkout | Online, by mail, by phone, or through an agent |
| Where the price comes from | An agent quotes your age, state and health answers | A quote online, or an information packet mailed to you |
| Medical exam | Depends on the product and amount, so ask your agent | None on the direct products. Simple application |
| Individual life shelf | Whole life, term life and universal life | Term, whole life, final expense, children's, accidental death |
| Coverage shown on the site | Not published. Varies by product and state | $100,000 adult and $30,000 child, limited by state |
One prints the offer in advance. The other assembles it around you.
The structural difference here is when the offer takes shape, and it decides most of the rest. Globe Life places a great deal of its coverage direct, so the terms are set out before you apply. Its life pages advertise a simple application with no medical exam, no waiting period and full coverage the first day, and they show $100,000 for adults and $30,000 for children, noting that face value may be limited by state. You can pull a quote online, ask for an information packet with rates by mail, or speak to an agent. The shape of the offer is the same whoever picks it up. American Amicable works the other way. Its site walks you through three steps: explore the products, find an agent, apply for coverage. Very little is settled until then, including which of its five insurance companies issues the contract, since that follows the product and your state. The agent builds the plan around your age, your state and your health answers, and an independent one can price two or three other carriers in the same sitting. One approach is decided in advance. The other is put together for you.
Who each one actually suits
American Amicable
A Waco, Texas group of five insurers that sells only through agents
- You would rather have a licensed agent read the health questions with you than answer them alone on a screen.
- You want more than one company quoted in the same conversation, which an independent agent carrying several carriers can do.
- You may need term or universal life rather than a small whole life policy, since American Amicable keeps all three on one shelf.
- You like that the group says it has been protecting generations since 1910 out of Waco, Texas, and shows more than a million active policies.
- You want a person with a name and a license number you can call back when something about the policy changes.
Globe Life
A publicly traded insurer built to sell life coverage direct to the public
- You want to start it yourself, since you can pull a quote online or have an information packet with rates mailed to you before you speak to anyone.
- You would rather apply on your own, online or by phone, in a few minutes and with no medical exam.
- You want the benefit in force right away, and the direct pages state no waiting period and full coverage the first day.
- You already know roughly what you need, and the adult coverage shown on the site is $100,000, with face value limited by state in some places.
- You want children's coverage from the same company and the same website, which Globe Life shows up to $30,000.
If you already hold one of them
If one of these is already in a drawer, value it before you shop it. On the American Amicable side the name on the contract may read Occidental, Pioneer American, Pioneer Security, iA American or American Amicable Life of Texas, and on the Globe Life side it will read Globe Life And Accident Insurance Company, or Globe Life Insurance Company of New York for New York residents. That is the name your family will need at claim time, so write it somewhere they will actually find it. Then check the face amount, the premium and the beneficiary against what your household would need today, because a policy issued years ago was priced on the health you had then. If all three still line up, keeping it is the right answer, and we will tell you so.
Common questions
Which is better, American Amicable or Globe Life?
Neither, in the abstract, because they are not sold the same way and that is most of the difference. American Amicable reaches people through licensed agents, so the health questions get asked in conversation and an independent agent can set two or three carriers side by side before anyone signs anything. Globe Life is built for a buyer who wants to handle it alone, with a quote you can pull online, an information packet it will mail you, and an application you can finish yourself. What either one costs depends on your age, your sex, your state and your health, so the only honest comparison is one where all of those are fixed and the company is the only thing that changes.
Who actually issues each policy?
American Amicable Group is five insurance companies: American Amicable Life Insurance Company of Texas, iA American Life Insurance Company, Occidental Life Insurance Company of North Carolina, Pioneer American Insurance Company and Pioneer Security Life Insurance Company. Which one appears on your contract depends on the product and your state, and the group describes those companies as United States subsidiaries of iA Financial Group, a Canadian company listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange. Globe Life is the marketing name for Globe Life Inc. and its subsidiaries. The coverage sold direct is issued by Globe Life And Accident Insurance Company of McKinney, Texas, and by Globe Life Insurance Company of New York for New York residents. Whichever name is on your contract, you can look it up at ambest.com or with your own state insurance department.
What does no waiting period mean on the Globe Life direct pages?
It means the plan is written to pay the full benefit from the first day rather than to phase it in over the first year or two. Globe Life states on its direct life pages that there is no waiting period and full coverage begins the first day. That is worth knowing because small whole life comes in both shapes across the industry. Some plans pay in full from day one for people whose health answers qualify, and others return premiums or pay a portion if a death from natural causes happens early. Whichever company you are looking at, ask which version you are being offered and read that part of the outline of coverage before you sign.
Does an agent have to come to my home to buy from American Amicable?
No. American Amicable sells through licensed agents rather than a web checkout, and its own site walks you to one, but where that conversation happens is up to you. Plenty of agents take the whole application by phone or on a video call and send the forms for electronic signature. If you would rather not meet in person, say so at the start, because it is a preference almost every agent can work around.
Does either one require a medical exam?
Globe Life states plainly on its direct pages that there is no medical exam and the application is simple. At American Amicable it depends on the product and the amount, since small whole life of the kind bought to cover a funeral is generally written from a page of health questions rather than a paramedical exam and lab work, while larger amounts usually involve more. Your agent can tell you exactly what your application requires before you fill anything in. The distinction worth holding onto is that no exam is not the same as no questions, and at most companies the answers are what decide which version of a plan you are offered.
Can I see a price before I talk to anyone?
With Globe Life you can get close on your own, and that is by design, because it sells a great deal of its coverage direct. Its site offers an online quote and will mail you an information packet with rates, so you can read the numbers at your own pace. American Amicable is built the other way. Its consumer site describes the three product types, whole life, term and universal life, and then hands you to an agent, so your price exists once that agent runs it for your age, your state and your health answers. If seeing a number yourself before you speak to anyone matters to you, that difference is worth knowing before you start.
How can I check the financial strength of each company?
Look up the issuing company rather than the brand on the brochure. Both groups have their claims paying ability rated by AM Best, and we do not print ratings here, because they change and a figure copied into an article ages badly. Take the exact insurer name from page one of your policy, search it at ambest.com, and you will have your answer in about a minute. It is also worth knowing that every licensed life insurer in the country is backed by the guaranty association in your state, up to limits your state sets.
Free · No obligation
The right answer depends on you, not on the brochure.
Rates for American Amicable and Globe Life both depend on your age and health, which means the better buy for your neighbour may be the worse buy for you. A licensed professional will price both against what you already have and tell you which is genuinely better, including when the honest answer is to keep what you have.
Mon-Sat · 10am-9pm
This comparison is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Product availability, pricing and underwriting differ by state, age and health, and change over time. Policy Review Center is a free comparison and referral service, not an insurance agency, insurer, or producer, and it connects you with independent licensed agents. Carrier names are used for reference only and do not imply any endorsement or affiliation.