The short answer
Yes. Mutual of Omaha is a real, state licensed insurance organisation, and it has been operating out of Omaha, Nebraska since 1909. Depending on which product you hold, your contract is issued by Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company or by one of its affiliated insurers, including United of Omaha Life Insurance Company and, for New York residents, Companion Life Insurance Company. If the Mutual of Omaha name is on the letter in your hand, you are looking at an insurer that has been in business since 1909, not a fake one.
Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company is a mutual insurer, which means it has no publicly traded shares and answers to its policyholders rather than to outside stockholders.
You know the name without ever having bought anything
This one runs backwards. With most insurers the question starts because nobody in the house recognises the name. Here it starts because everybody does. The company name has been on American television since 1963, when a wildlife series carrying it premiered on a national network and then ran for decades. Add a parent's Medicare supplement, or a dental card sitting in a wallet, and almost everyone has the name filed away somewhere. What almost nobody has is a memory of buying anything. So when an envelope arrives about a life policy, a long term care plan or an annuity, familiarity and doubt turn up together, and that combination is what sends people to a search bar. The second half of it is range. One brand covers Medicare supplement, hospital indemnity, dental, long term care, critical illness, life insurance, annuities and workplace benefits, and the name is on mortgage and reverse mortgage services too. Very few insurers span that much ground under a single name. A letter about a product you did not know the company sold is a normal thing to receive, and the line beginning 'underwritten by' near the bottom of the page is what tells you which product line you are actually holding.
How to check it yourself in about a minute
You should never have to take our word for it, or the company's. Every one of these is free, public, and works for any insurer you ever want to look up.
- Read the fine print for the underwriting company. Near the bottom of any letter or brochure there is a line that starts with "underwritten by" and names a specific insurer. That name tells you which product line you are dealing with, which is usually the question you actually wanted answered.
- Look that insurer up with your own state. Your state department of insurance publishes a free licence lookup, and naic.org will point you to the right one. Search the insurer name exactly as it appears in the fine print, not the brand name on the envelope. An authorised insurer comes back straight away.
- Match the policy number against something you already hold. Compare the policy or certificate number on the mail with a statement, a benefits card or a policy schedule you already have. Letterhead is easy to copy. A number that matches your own records is the real confirmation.
- Reach the company through details you found yourself. If you want to call or write, use the contact route printed on your own policy documents or on the company website you navigated to directly, rather than a number printed on an unexpected letter. That is sound practice with any sender.
- Check financial strength independently. Insurer financial strength ratings are published by rating agencies and can be looked up free at ambest.com. Search the underwriting company from the fine print, since ratings are assigned to individual insurers rather than to the brand.
- Confirm what kind of coverage it is before you act. A Medicare supplement, a dental plan and a life policy are three completely different things with three different renewal cycles. Knowing which one the letter refers to decides whether it needs a reply this week or not at all.
What is actually going on
- Several insurer names, one organisation. United of Omaha Life Insurance Company, United World Life Insurance Company and Companion Life Insurance Company are affiliated insurers that issue particular product lines. Seeing one of those names instead of Mutual of Omaha is normal, not a warning sign.
- New York gets a different issuer. United of Omaha is not licensed in New York, so life insurance and annuities for New York residents are issued by Companion Life Insurance Company. If you live in New York, that is the name you should expect to see.
- The breadth of products is genuine. Health related coverage, life insurance, annuities, workplace benefits and mortgage services all sit under the one name, which is a wider spread than most insurers carry. That is why a household can hold two Mutual of Omaha products that have nothing to do with each other, on separate renewal cycles, serviced by separate teams.
- A mutual has no shareholders. Because it is a mutual insurer rather than a stock company, there is no share price to look up and no quarterly earnings release. Financial information is filed with state regulators and summarised by rating agencies instead.
- The television association is real history. The wildlife series that carried the company name premiered on network television in 1963 and ran for decades. It is the reason so many people recognise the brand without ever having bought anything from it.
Common questions
Is Mutual of Omaha a real insurance company?
Yes. It is a licensed United States insurer headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska, and it has been in business since 1909. You can confirm its licence, and the licence of whichever affiliated insurer issued your contract, through your own state department of insurance in about a minute.
Why does my policy say United of Omaha instead of Mutual of Omaha?
Because life insurance and annuities are underwritten by United of Omaha Life Insurance Company, an affiliated insurer within the same organisation. It is the correct name for that product line. New York residents will see Companion Life Insurance Company instead, since United of Omaha is not licensed there.
I got a Mutual of Omaha letter about Medicare. Is that the same company that sold me life insurance?
Same organisation, different product and often a different issuing insurer. Some Medicare supplement plans are underwritten by United World Life Insurance Company, while life insurance comes from United of Omaha Life Insurance Company. The line beginning "underwritten by" near the bottom of the page will tell you which one you are holding.
Someone told me the Mutual of Omaha mail I received is a scam. Is it?
Almost certainly not. The brand markets across a lot of product lines, so people regularly receive material about coverage they did not know the company sold. Check the underwriting company named in the fine print, then look that insurer up with your state. Once you know which product line the letter refers to, you will know whether it needs a reply at all.
What does it mean that Mutual of Omaha is a mutual company?
A mutual insurer is not owned by outside stockholders and has no publicly traded shares, so it answers to its policyholders. In practical terms it means you will not find a stock ticker for it, and financial information comes from state regulatory filings and rating agencies rather than from quarterly earnings reports.
Should I keep a Mutual of Omaha policy I already have?
Often yes, and that is a perfectly good outcome. Coverage bought years ago was priced on the health you had then, and if your health has changed since, replacing it can cost more or may not be available on the same terms. Understand what you hold before you change anything.
How do I find out how much coverage I actually have?
Your policy schedule states the benefit amount, the premium and the renewal terms. If you cannot find your documents, the issuing insurer named in the fine print can send you a copy. Start there, because the benefit amount is what makes the price make sense.
How can I check that an insurance company is licensed in my state?
Every state runs a free public lookup through its department of insurance, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners keeps a consumer portal at naic.org that points you to the right one. Search the insurer by name and you will see whether it is authorised to write business in your state. It takes about a minute and it works for any company, not just this one.
I got mail about a policy I do not remember buying. What should I do?
Do not ignore it, and do not act on the letter alone. Match the policy number on the letter against your own records first. If it matches something you hold, the mail is almost certainly a servicing notice or a rebrand notice. If nothing matches, contact the insurer using the details on your own statement or on the company website you looked up yourself, rather than a number printed on an unexpected letter. That habit protects you generally, whoever the sender is.
Free · No obligation
The company is real. Is the policy right?
A licensed professional will go through your Mutual of Omaha coverage with you and tell you plainly what it pays, what it costs, and whether anything better is genuinely available at your age and health. We are independent, and a review that ends in keep what you have is a perfectly good outcome.
Mon-Sat · 10am-9pm
This guide is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Licensing and company details change, so confirm anything important with your state department of insurance. Policy Review Center is a free comparison and referral service, not an insurance agency, insurer, or producer, and it connects you with independent licensed agents. Carrier names are used for reference only and do not imply any endorsement or affiliation.